"What a thousand acres of Silphiums looked like when they tickled the bellies of the buffalo is a question never again to be answered, and perhaps not even asked." -Aldo Leopold
This post is related to the rearing work I shared previously of the Orgyia leucostigma (white-marked tussock moth). During a caterpillar hunting outing with Sarah, I found what was obviously a cocoon of a tussock moth. I can’t say for certain it belonged to O. leucostigma, but it is likely. So, I photographed it in the field and brought it home, keeping it separate from the O. leucostigma cocoons that I was rearing that were collected from my yard. As time went on and the other cocoons I was rearing began producing moths, I figured something was going to be different with the one pictured below.
A tussock moth (Orgyia sp.) cocoon collected on 21, Sep, 2024 at Onondaga Cave State Park. Note the long setae from the tussock moth caterpillar that are incorporated into their cocoons
Checking the container on 6-October, I found this beautiful Orgichneumon calcatorius, an Ichneumonid wasp with a Holarctic range that is a parasitoid of moths in the Orgyia and Dasychira genera. After taking a few photos, I let it go in the backyard. After emerging, females of the species mate and then overwinter as adults utilizing crevices in tree bark. In the spring and summer of the following year, they look for new caterpillars to insert their eggs.
A newly emerged Orgichneumon calcatorius with the pupa and cocoon that hosted it in the background.
A closeup look of the brilliantly patterned Orgichneumon calcatorius
Small Necklace Moth Hypsoropha hormos fam. Erebidae Host plant: Found on persimmon (Diospyros virginiana) Date found: 3, Aug, 2024 Locations Found: Cuivre River State Park, St. Louis County, MO Notes: Described by one of the fathers of entomology, German lepidopterist, Jacob Hübner.
Virginia Creeper Sphinx Moth Darapsa myron fam. Sphingidae Host plant: Found on wild grape (Vitis sp.) Date found: 13, Sep, 2024 Locations Found: River’s Edge Park, St. Louis County, MO Notes: Other common name is hog sphinx.
Lace-capped Caterpillar Ianassa lignicolor fam. Notodontidae Host plant: Oaks and other Fagaceae members Date found: 21, Sep, 2024 Locations Found: Onondaga Cave State Park, Crawford County, MO Notes: Adult moth is named white-streaked prominent.
Ianassa lignicolor
Characteristic head mottling of Ianassa lignicolor head capsule
This autumn I was fortunate to have this really interesting experience with a common but fascinating moth species. I invite you to read about it and see the photography.
New documented host plant (Nymphaeaceae) and life history documentation for the highly polyphagous moth, Orgyia leucostigma (Lepidoptera: Erebidae), in eastern Missouri.
Orgyia leucostigma Smith, 1797 is a moth species in the family Erebidae that is found throughout eastern North America and is known to be extremely polyphagous. Commonly known as the white-marked tussock moth, O. leucostigma has been recorded using 166 plant species in 55 families as hosts, mostly consisting of deciduous plants, but coniferous and herbaceous plants have also been recorded (Robinson et al. 2023).
Larvae of Orgyia leucostigma feeding on Nymphaea odorata.
In early September 2024, I observed six mid- to late-instar larvae of O. leucostigma, each feeding on the leaves of Nymphaea odorata (Nymphaeaceae) that were growing in a small artificial “pond” in my St. Louis County, MO suburban yard. Unfortunately, these insects consumed every available leaf of N. odorata in the pond before they could pupate. The only other species in the pond available to them was the exotic Pontederia crassipes (water hyacinth), which they did not readily consume. I was able to locate and remove five final-instar larvae from the remnants of the original host leaves and placed them in an outdoor cage where they successfully switched to feeding on leaves of Quercus muehlenbergii and Q. imbricaria (both Fagaceae). Within seven days, all five larvae built cocoons to pupate within.
Larvae of Orgyia leucostigma running out of leaf. Leaves of exotic Pontederia crassipes (water hyacinth) seen surrounding hostplant leaf.
To my knowledge, this is the first documentation of a nymphaeaceous host plant for O. leucostigma, which expands the host range of this already highly polyphagous species by another family. Unfortunately, the caterpillars did not reach pupation feeding on N. odorata alone, so the ability of O. leucostigma to reach adulthood on this host cannot be confirmed yet. However, the fact that five larvae of O. leucostigma were able to reach the final larval instar feeding solely on N. odorata makes this highly likely.
Larvae of Orgyia leucostigma finishing its larval stage on leaves of Quercus imbricaria (shingle oak).
Life history of Orgyia leucostigma The lifecycle of O. leucostigma begins as an egg, typically laid in masses by the adult female. Eggs are laid in late summer or early fall on tree bark, branches, or other surfaces. A single female can lay anywhere between 100 to 600 eggs. These eggs are small, round, and white to pale yellow in color, and are coated in a protective frothy substance produced by the female to safeguard them from predators and environmental factors.
Two of five cocoons of Orgyia leucostigma that were raised primarily on the leaves of Nymphaea odorata.
Lepidopterans use a variety of strategies in overwintering. In the case of O. leucostigma, the eggs remain dormant over the winter, entering a state of diapause, a period of suspended development that allows them to withstand harsh winter conditions. They hatch in the spring when the weather warms, typically around late April or early May, coinciding with the budding of trees that will serve as food for the larvae.
One of five Orgyia leucostigma females that eclosed in late September and early October.
After hatching, the larvae emerge as small, hairy caterpillars. This larval stage is perhaps the most recognizable and distinctive phase of O. leucostigma. The caterpillars are known for their colorful and tufted appearance, with a series of tufts (or tussocks) of hair along their backs and two long black “pencils” of hair protruding from both the front and back ends. The body is primarily yellow or cream-colored, with a pattern of red and black markings.
One of approximately two-dozen male Orgyia leucostigma that were attracted to our screen porch, presumably by the pheromones released by the females.
As discussed above, the larvae feed on a wide variety of trees and shrubs, including both deciduous and coniferous species. In our area, oak, maple, and willow, are among the most common hosts. The larvae are voracious feeders and can cause significant defoliation when present in large numbers, which can lead to tree stress, although healthy trees typically recover without long-term damage.
The males found the stationary Orgyia leucostigma females once placed in their enclosure.
Once the larva has reached its final instar, it will spin a cocoon in a sheltered location, often on the trunk or branches of trees, beneath loose bark, or on the sides of buildings. The cocoon is made from silk and incorporates most of the caterpillar’s own urticating body hairs, offering added protection from predators.
Inside the cocoon, the caterpillar transforms into a pupa, a resting stage during which the most dramatic metamorphosis occurs. The pupal stage typically lasts 10-14 days, during which time the organism undergoes a complete transformation from a larva into an adult moth.
Upon completion of the pupal stage, the adult moth emerges. The adult form of O. leucostigma exhibits strong sexual dimorphism. The males are small, grayish-brown moths with a wingspan of about 25-35 mm. They have feathered antennae that they use to detect pheromones released by females from a considerable distance.
Within minutes of a presumed successful copulation, a female Orgyia leucostigma begins oviposition, forming a large foam-encapsulated egg mass.
In contrast, the females are wingless and remain on or near their cocoons after emerging. They are larger than the males and have a plump, cylindrical body covered with dense hairs. Since they are flightless, females rely on releasing pheromones to attract males for mating. After mating, the female lays eggs near the cocoon, starting the cycle again. The female typically dies shortly after laying her eggs, while the male lives a few days longer in search of other mates.
Due to the stationary habit of the females, it is fascinating that all dispersal is dependent on the larvae in this species. To do this efficiently, early-instar larvae will often “balloon,” letting out an amount of silk to catch the wind, thus allowing them to move to new areas much quicker than by crawling. This dispersal mechanism is also practiced by many spiders.
A worn male Orgyia leucostigma rests nearby as the female continues to oviposition.
In this specific case, all five of the pupa that I reared produced female adults and each of these eclosed exactly 10 days after cocoons/pupa were formed. At dawn of each morning following the females emergence, I walked the outside perimeter of our screened porch wherein the screened moth enclosure was contained. Each morning I found up to six male adult O. leucostigma that I captured and placed in the enclosure containing the females.
The extent of the egg masses of Orgyia leucostigma was astounding. The females were mostly eggs!
Mating appeared to be very brief and within minutes of contact by a male, each female began ovipositing. It was quite shocking observing the differences in size of the females before and after their egg masses where completed. See photos below that I attempted to document these changes.
A nearly completed Orgyia leucostigma egg mass along with her larger and older sister and a potential mate.
While observing and photographing these activities, I happened to notice that a jumping spider (F. Salticidae) was attacking one of the females prior to her ovipositing. The spider must have come from the oak branches that I placed in the enclosure to finish rearing the caterpillars. I took enough time to take a few photos of this and then removed the spider with a pair of forceps. I noticed a drop of hemolymph on the back of the female after removing the spider. However, the female did not seem too bothered by this and created her egg mass within a couple of hours of this incident.
A female Orgyia leucostigma that was attacked by a jumping spider (fam. Salticidae) that must have been hiding within the oak branches. The spider was removed and although it is likely the moth received a wound, she later completed ovipositioning.
Caterpillars of this species are often found during my caterpillar hunts. Sometimes they are so plentiful as to be annoying when hoping for rarer quarry. I had read about the stationary eggbound females of this species but had little hope of ever actually seeing one in person. I very much enjoyed documenting these activities and I will try my best at overwintering these egg masses to fruition.
Literature Cited
Robinson, G. S., P. R. Ackery, I. Kitching, G. W Beccaloni and L. M. Hernández (2023). HOSTS (from HOSTS – a Database of the World’s Lepidopteran Hostplants) [Data set resource]. Natural History Museum. Available from https://data.nhm.ac.uk/dataset/hosts/resource/877f387a-36a3-486c-a0c1-b8d5fb69f85a (last accessed 16 Sep 2024).
Today’s caterpillar is a little confusing in a a couple of ways. This individual is either Erynnis juvenalis (Juvenal’s duskywing) or E. horatius (Horace’s duskywing). Both species look pretty much identical as larva and both use several oak species as host plants. I’m no expert but it seems that these are best identified to species in their adult form.
Which dusky you be?
The second confusing thing is that I found this individual while beat-sheeting a small ash tree (Fraxinus sp.) in mid-July at Onondaga Cave State Park in Crawford County, MO. From my understanding, both species are obligate oak feeders. This might mean it had fallen from a higher oak and landed in the ash tree, or it might be pre-pupal and looking for a place to pupate. Most often Caterpillars move from their host plants to pupate in a neighboring tree or plant.
Juvenal or Horace?
If you have any thoughts or tips on how I might discern this guy to species with just a couple of simple photos and the information I supplied, please let me know.
For tonight’s caterpillar, I am featuring the Sphingidae family member, Amorpha juglandis – the walnut sphinx moth. This is the only species in the monotypic genus, Amorpha, a name that is shared with a plant genus that holds our leadplant (Amorpha canescens) and false indigo bush (A. fruticosa). This name comes from the Greek – amorphos- meaning formless or mishappen. This describes the lack of wing and keel petals of the corolla of these beans. For the moth, I am not completely certain, but it may have to do with the unique shape and placement of the rear wings when this moth is at rest. This species is very easily identified in both larval and adult forms.
First up are a couple of early instar brood mates that I found on the same walnut tree in mid-July at Kaintuck Hollow in Phelps County, MO.
Next up is an older cat found at Schoolcraft Prairie in Washington County, MO in mid-August. Caterpillars of this species at this stage are infamous for its defensive displays when harassed, including emitting a high-pitched squeak, thrashing and biting. Unfortunately, this one was pretty chill, so I could not show this off to the folks I was with.
Amorpha juglandis – the walnut sphinx moth
Finally, on the same night we photographed the caterpillar pictured immediately above, an adult male moth was attracted to our blacklight setup. This was my first looks at the adult form of this species.
Today’s caterpillar is an interesting species from an obscure family – Thyrididae, or window-winged moths. Pseudothyris sepulchralis (mournful thyris) is sharp looking as a caterpillar as well as an adult moth. This species is a specialist on greenbriers (Smilax sp.) and this individual was found rolled in a Smilax leaf about head-high at Kaintuck Hollow in Phelps County, MO in mid-July.
I’m pleased to say I found a “holy grail” caterpillar species this year. Unfortunately, at the time, I did not know what I had found. On July 13th, while searching right off a parking lot at Huzzah Conservation Area in Crawford County, MO, I found this smallish bird poop mimic caterpillar. I knew I had seen this one in photos before, but on this day I had left my field guides at home and I was in an area with absolutely no cell phone coverage.
Mid instar of Acronicta funeralis (paddle caterpillar)
After getting back home, I identified this as a member of the Noctuidae family – Acronicta funeralis, aka the paddle caterpillar. It gets its common name from the paired paddlelike subdorsal setae that are present on the final instar of the caterpillar. I really wish I had known what I had found at the time. I would have brought this guy home to rear in order to get photos of the final instar of this cat. This species is rare enough that it might be the one and only that I find, but I think if I try hard enough, others will come in time.
Mid instar of Acronicta funeralis (paddle caterpillar)
Here are a few of the members of the Noctuidae family of moth caterpillars we found in 2023. Commonly know as “owlet moths,” this is a very diverse clade that is still continuing to be revised and divided. Until recently, this was the largest lepidopteran family. A number of economically important members are found in this family, such as armyworm and cutworm species.
American Dagger Moth (Acronicta americana) Noctuidae, Hodges#9200 Rarely a day on the hunt goes by without finding one or more of these little beauties. This guy was not perturbed at all by us stopping to watch. It continued to chow on the leaf as I photographed it.
Two-spotted Oak Punkie (Meganola phylla) Noctuidae, Hodges#8983.1 Found on Quercus alba (white oak).
Eclipsed Oak Dagger (Acronicta increta) Noctuidae, Hodges#9249 Not that I keep great records but I am pretty certain that this one is by far the most abundant caterpillar we come across while looking on oaks. I probably find five of these to one of other species on oaks. There are a few similar species. The second one may be a different species of Acronicta.
Noctuidae (Acronicta sp.) This is what I get for not taking photos of some of these from multiple angles. Not even the experts on iNaturalist could get this guy to species using this one image. It was a gorgeous and large caterpillar.
Gold Moth (Basilodes pepita) Noctuidae, Hodges#9781 Finally – I am sharing a cat that does not feed on woody plants. Also, a rare case of a moth that is gorgeous in both adult and larval forms. Unfortunately, this was a pretty early instar and does not show the bright and contrasting colors of older caterpillars. The gold moth feeds exclusively on Verbina species (wingstems, crownbeards).